Reset password:

Strategic analysis
The Non-Future of Advertising

Even if digital advertising budgets where to rise 500%, it would still not cover the cost of traditional media.



Written by on December 20, 2011

There is an ongoing discussion about the future of advertising. On one hand we have print advertising, which is in decline - in some places drastically. Many newspaper executives apparently believe the "worst is over" and that while it will continue to decline for 2-3 more years, it will eventually stabilize.

It won't...

Then we have online advertising, which is increasing. This sounds very good, but it isn't.

In this article, I am going to explain why advertising doesn't have a future for publishers. Partly because it has already passed the point of no return; the media just hasn't realized it yet.

Print advertising

Every single newspaper or magazine relies on advertising first to stay in business. Sure, they also have subscriptions and newsstand sales, but advertising makes up the bulk of the revenue.

For the New York Times, for instance, advertising makes up 60% of the total revenue (subscriptions/single copy sales make up 31%).

The problem of course is that print advertising revenue has declined dramatically over the past couple of years. The New York Times advertising revenue has dropped from $1.7 billion to $1.3 billion from 2008 to 2010 (25%). Vogue has dropped 48% from 2009 to 2011.

Of course it is not all bad. The Financial Times says that advertising decline has flat lined for most of 2011 after a catastrophic summer of 2010.

So ...maybe it will stabilize? Right? ....Please?

I'm sorry. It is too late for that, and here is why.

Who is buying the advertising? It's the brands. What do brands care about? Well, if you ask the CEO he would say *sales!!*. But if you ask the person actually buying the ads, the CMOs (marketing executives), most of them have no clue. They still believe that exposure equals sales.

For the past 100 years, marketing executives have been living a lie. They believe that when they buy a full page ad in a popular magazine, the numbers they are given are actually something useful.

Subscribe to read the rest of this 22 page report...

Try it free for one week

Register to try out Baekdal Plus completely for free for one week.

...or subscribe today



As a PLUS member, you can share anything on, with anyone, everywhere. When you share a plus article with a friend, they can read the full article for free. They will even get notified that you are the one who shared it - with a link to your Twitter profile. Just in case they want to follow you, now that you are being such a nice person!

Share on

Thomas Baekdal

Thomas Baekdal

Founder of Baekdal, author, writer, strategic consultant, and new media advocate.


Check out my book: THE SHIFT - from print to digital and beyond? Free for Baekdal Plus subscribers, $8.79 on Amazon.

There is always more...

Will AIs Replace the Media? »



BuzzFeed Tasty is Fascinating »